When we started planning our very first OTH Holiday gift guide, we kept going back to the central pillar that started this whole thing in the first place: What does it mean to hone our own taste as we also observe and learn how the most interesting people have honed theirs?
Good taste is sort of arbitrary. But there is a consistent through-line that gets us interested in something out of the ordinary—something that grabs our attention, sparks desire, and makes us wonder about where it came from, and also where it’s been all our lives.
That starting point became our True North for choosing all the exceptionally great things we’ve gathered here. These 60-ish items are good-looking and high-functioning: practical pots and pans (sometimes people just want a gift they’ll really USE), an abundance of intriguing pantry additions, sweet vintage collectibles for dinner parties and home dinners galore—ALL of which made the cut for our list and, we hope, everyone on YOURS, too.

A collection of Indie food zines. Very IYKYK.






From left: Standart (each issue comes with coffee), biannual food/art pub Synonym, Berlin-based mag Famous For My Dinner Parties, wine fave Noble Rot, Roads & Kingdoms (which won a James Beard Award this year and hosts small-group culinary journeys), Cake Zine (co-founded by OTH contributor Aliza Abarbanel :).
Or this glorious lot of vintage Gourmets wrapped in craft paper.
“The last non-stick pan you’ll ever buy.”
And how about a little love note tucked inside with the secret to frying the perfect egg…(like, how did we not know this??).
Or splurge on a full kitchen set (made especially for small apartments…genius).
Not your ordinary placemats.
Do we kind of want to stitch these together and make a wall tapestry instead of using them on the table? Highly possible…
Service Projects Saloon porcelain deep plate.
John bought a set recently + loves them.
Plus, more heirloom-like ceramics.






From left: A 1940s McCoy Dutch Boy cookie jar, antique Mochaware salt shaker, Serax Carte Blanche porcelain teapot, Liz Rowland chard hand-painted ceramic mug, King custom 10-year platter, tabletop set made in England with a chic navy rim.
Items they haven’t replaced but (probably) should.




From left: Aarke stainless steel electric kettle (a favorite of MPC founders Emma Leigh Macdonald + Rowan Spencer), Zwiesel Glas Sensa white wine glass, set of 6 (break-resistant!), the new-ish compact (but just as powerful) Beast blender that comes in some very pleasing shades of mist and sand, a classic-looking 5-ply stainless steel 8-quart pot.
Maria Schoettler 2027 Eat Local calendar.
Very good pantry stuff that ALWAYS kills.









From left: Delicious Springs Fireplace Original Hot Sauce Trio (the Tesuque is great in a Bloody Mary), the best buttermilk pancake mix from Phoenicia Diner, Sessy Soy Sauce for a little umami, FOND cultured cream + scallion potato chips (cooked in grass-fed tallow), IKEA ketchup + mustard—aka condiments that look like pop art, Share sourdough crackers (handmade with ❤️ in Detroit), Fly By Jing Sauce Sampler, Flamingo Estate Fennel Flower olive oil, actually good decaf coffee by Heist.
Tequila that’s also art.
Some hyper-specific kitchen gear/gadgets.






From left: The very BEST salt and pepper grinders from HexClad, the cute/cool Rocco Mini Mini Fridge, the always-sold-out SharkNinja Belgian waffle maker, a Rorra Countertop filtration system (John’s a FAN), ARTSN cutting board set, Balmuda The Teppanyaki (like Benihana at home!).
Something sparkly.


Two of our faves: 00 Wines 2022 Pinot Meunier Champagne + Ghia Le Fizz.
And a Gohar World lace bottle apron to dress up the bottle.
Yes, it’s kind of pointless, but it’s also completely irresistible.
Just a cute sticker/stocking stuffer.
Icebreakers = more good reasons to get invited to the best parties.




From left: Piecework Puzzles “Butter”, vintage Fika play cards that celebrate the Swedish tradition of coffee/tea, baked treats, and good company, Food Stories Conversation Deck, House of Marble Cheese and Crackers game (yes, that’s a Swiss wind-up racer).
Chic candlestick holders = more good reasons to throw the best parties.
Christene spotted these beauties ⬆️ at Antik on Atlantic Ave last week. We fell hard for them, so here’s a few other options ⬇️:



From left: Brass candlestick holders (set of 3), Nickey Kehoe green wavy candle holder, Toast Longpi Stubby candle holder.
A plush, tomato-red blanket.
Pro tip: The best host always has a cozy throw on hand for guests.
Things that open…things.



From left: MG&Co. bottle opener with semi-precious stone cubes, a tiny Japanese can opener, Alessi x The Mark corkscrew (a collector’s piece!).
BOOKS!




Some titles we’re loving right now, from left: Richard Scarry’s Busy, Busy Cookbook for kids, NYC Restaurant Ads: 1981–1998 (yes to nostalgia), A24’s ode to late-night eating AKA Scrounging: A Cookbook, the first-ever book dedicated to Bodega Cats of New York.
A grow-your-own starter kit.
Pair Do Grow: A Guide to Growing Vegetables by Alice Holden with a set of seeds from Row 7.
An ode to the city we ❤️.
Like Timothée Chalamet, our drink of choice is “New York City tap water, please, no ice.”
The OTH Brand Directory
00 Wines, A24, Aarke, Alessi, Antik, ARTSN, Balmuda, Beast, Springs Fireplace, Flamingo Estate, Fly By Jing, FOND, Ghia, Gohar World, Heist, HexClad, IKEA, Maria Schoettler, Matilda Goad, Nickey Kehoe, Piecework Puzzles, Rocco, Rorra, Row 7, Serax, Service Projects, Sessy, Share, SharkNinja, Toast, Zwiesel Glas.
Thanks for joining us today. A reminder that if you click on or buy anything throughout this newsletter, we might earn a small commission at no cost to you.















I'd add www.stickcandles.com to your list. Great holiday gift for the dining table!